WikiMSK:Peer Review Process

From WikiMSK

Revision as of 08:38, 14 May 2021 by Jeremy (talk | contribs)

Content may be published in an unfinished form, and this is encouraged. Articles have an indicator on the top right as to their level of completeness. Quarter circle articles are called stubs, half circles are partially finished, and three quarter circles are complete. The aim is for complete articles to then be peer reviewed, and these articles are indicated with a green circle, with the date of review, and a box with the peer review details at the top. These articles may still be changed, but readers can refer back to the older version that was reviewed.

In the event of a disagreement about the content, the lead and deputy editors have the final say but it is preferred to denote where there was a disagreement.

None of the authors, contributors, sponsors, administrators, or anyone else connected with WikiMSK in any way whatsoever can be responsible for the appearance of any inaccurate information or for your use of the information contained in or linked from these web pages.

User Accounts

  • Editing users’ identity and credentials - All applicants are verified as being eligible (members of NZAMM) by the lead editor. The NZAMM has a detailed vetting process for membership which requires relevant credentials. It is up to the user whether they want to publicly display their full name and details in their user pages.
  • Peer reviewers identity and credentials - All peer reviewers are required to disclose their full name. Peer reviewers must be either fellows of the NZAMM, or another relevant specialist.
  • Editing users’ conflicts of interest - Conflict of interest statements are mandatory on the user pages of the Lead and Deputy editors, peer reviewers, and encouraged for all other editing users.
  • Administrators’ identity - Public disclosure of identity is mandatory for the Lead and Deputy Editors.
User Type Eligibility Public Identity Statement Public Conflict of Interest Statement
Lead and Deputy Editors NZAMM Member Mandatory Mandatory
Standard Accounts NZAMM Member Optional Optional
Peer Reviewers NZAMM Fellow Mandatory Mandatory